By Team Patel | Douglas Elliman Real Estate | October 2026
With mortgage rates hovering around 7.40%, buying a home on Long Island has become increasingly challenging for many families.
As real estate professionals, we're seeing buyers focus on one question more than ever:
"What will my monthly mortgage payment be?"
For sellers, this creates an interesting opportunity.
When a home isn't attracting the right offers, the traditional solution is often to reduce the asking price. But what if there were another way to make the home more affordable without reducing the actual purchase price?
Let's explore how a $20,000 price reduction compares with offering a buyer $20,000 toward mortgage discount points.
A Real Long Island Example: 41 Hopes Avenue, Holtsville
Consider 41 Hopes Avenue in Holtsville, currently listed for $649,999.
This three-bedroom, two-bath ranch in the Sachem School District features central air conditioning, a finished basement, an in-ground pool, an attached garage, and fully owned solar panels.
Annual property taxes are listed at $9,989.
Now imagine a qualified buyer with 20% down who loves the property but is concerned about the monthly payment.
The seller is willing to negotiate $20,000 to help make the transaction work.
Which strategy could be more effective?
Option 1: Reduce the Purchase Price by $20,000
Under this scenario, the seller reduces the purchase price from $649,999 to $629,999.
Assuming a 20% down payment, a 30-year fixed mortgage at 7.40%, and estimated homeowners insurance of $2,400 annually:
Purchase price: $629,999
Down payment: $126,000
Mortgage amount: approximately $504,000
Monthly principal and interest: $3,490
Monthly property taxes: $832
Monthly homeowners insurance: $200
Total estimated monthly payment: $4,522
This reduces the buyer's mortgage balance and down payment requirement. However, because the mortgage rate remains at 7.40%, the monthly payment is still relatively high.
Option 2: Keep the Asking Price and Offer $20,000 Toward Mortgage Discount Points
Now consider a different approach.
Instead of lowering the purchase price, the seller agrees to contribute $20,000 toward the buyer's mortgage costs, with the goal of purchasing a permanently lower interest rate.
For illustration, let's assume the lender can use that contribution to reduce the buyer's 30-year fixed mortgage rate from 7.40% to 6.40%.
The numbers would look like this:
Purchase price: $649,999
Down payment: $130,000
Mortgage amount: approximately $520,000
Monthly principal and interest at 6.40%: $3,253
Monthly property taxes: $832
Monthly homeowners insurance: $200
Total estimated monthly payment: $4,285
That's approximately $237 less per month than the $20,000 price-reduction scenario, despite purchasing the home at a higher price.
Over five years, that difference represents approximately $14,220 in monthly cash-flow savings.
The actual rate available must be confirmed by a mortgage lender. A $20,000 credit does not automatically guarantee a one-percentage-point rate reduction.
Why This Strategy Can Benefit Sellers
A $20,000 price reduction and a $20,000 seller concession can have a similar effect on a seller's proceeds before transaction-specific expenses.
But they can have very different effects on a buyer's monthly affordability.
A lower mortgage rate may make the home more attractive to buyers who are comfortable with the purchase price but concerned about the monthly payment.
For sellers, offering financing assistance may be a valuable negotiating tool, particularly when competing properties are also trying to attract qualified buyers.
The strategy must be structured correctly, with lender approval, an adequate appraisal, and compliance with mortgage-program concession limits.
When Is a Price Reduction the Better Choice?
A seller concession isn't always the best solution.
A price reduction may be more effective when the home is priced above comparable properties, when buyers need a smaller down payment, or when an appraisal may not support the current asking price.
Similarly, buyers who expect to refinance or sell within a few years may benefit less from paying substantial upfront costs for a permanent rate reduction.
The decision should consider the buyer's expected ownership period, the lender's actual rate quote, and the seller's net proceeds.
The Team Patel Perspective
In today's Long Island real estate market, successful selling requires more than simply putting a home on the market and waiting for offers.
It requires understanding what buyers are struggling with and finding creative, practical solutions that benefit both sides.
Sometimes a price reduction is the right move. Other times, a carefully structured seller concession can create more meaningful monthly savings for a buyer.
The goal isn't simply to lower the price. It's to increase the value buyers see in purchasing your home.
At Team Patel, we combine local market knowledge, strategic pricing, creative marketing, and experienced negotiation to help our clients navigate changing market conditions.
Whether you're selling in Holtsville, Setauket, Stony Brook, Port Jefferson, Smithtown, or anywhere across Suffolk and Nassau Counties, we can help you evaluate the strategy that makes the most sense for your property.
We set the bar, and then we raise it.
Team Patel | Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Devang Patel & Pinky Parikh
Residential & Commercial Real Estate
631-220-2860
Guiding You Home Across Long Island.
Disclaimer: Calculations are illustrative and based on a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage with 20% down. Insurance is estimated. Taxes are based on the property's MLS listing and may change. The 6.40% rate is hypothetical, and actual discount-point pricing, lender approval, loan eligibility, closing costs, and seller-concession limits will vary. Seller credits cannot generally be applied to the buyer's down payment.
Check out this article next
